Benue

Unit 2: The Middle Benue: Visual Resemblances, Connected Histories

The largest and most ethnically and geographically complex of the Benue subregions is the Middle Benue. During the first half of the nineteenth century, the establishment of Muslim Fulani states and the simultaneous intensification of slave raiding dramatically impacted the diverse peoples living there. These events were followed by further disruptive outside influences in the form of British colonization and the arrival of Christian missionaries starting in the early twentieth century.

Most contemporary ethnic identities within this area crystallized only during the colonial period, because the British needed them for administrative purposes, and local people embraced them out of a sense of belonging. The works of more than ten of these culture groups—with an emphasis on the Jukun, Mumuye, Chamba, Wurkun/Bikwin, Goemai, Montol, and Kantana/Kulere—are featured here.

Distinctive to the arts of the Middle Benue region are sculptures in human form, hybridized human-animal horizontal masks, and remarkable vertical masks that may have functioned as “walking sculptures.” The striking resemblances among these art objects speak to historical relationships and ritual alliances among neighboring peoples. All across the region, wooden figures served as intermediaries in rituals aimed at healing and protecting the community, especially from such crises as epidemics, drought, and warfare. And, horizontal and vertical masks were used in performances associated with funerals and remembering the dead, initiating youth, ensuring or celebrating a successful harvest, or healing the sick.

The figurative sculptures of the Middle Benue region are decidedly different from the favored maternal image of the Lower Benue. They are geometric in approach, and many examples have long held special appeal for modernist artists and collectors, who admired especially the abstraction and dynamic postures of Mumuye figurative sculpture. The highly stylized circular horns of the “buffalo” crest masks of the Kantana and Kulere peoples are also notable for their bold minimalist elegance. This section of the exhibition also includes Super-8 footage of several masquerade genres where performers wore voluminous raffia capes along with animal-human hybrid masks. The films were taken in 1965 and 1970 by UCLA art historian Arnold Rubin, whose fieldwork laid the foundation for this exhibition. 

Lesson 10: Ancestor Sculptures of the Eastern Gongola Valley

Background Information

Although most sacred objects in the Upper Benue are made of clay, a tradition of making ancestral representations in wood also existed. Large and imposing male figures (figs. 10.1–3) may have functioned as effigies of dead chiefs, erected during the post-burial funerary rites held by a cluster of related Eastern Gongola peoples—the ‘Bəna, Yungur, and Mboi. These rituals were held before the planting season so that the blessings of the deceased could be conferred. Although we know that these rituals were held, nothing resembling these rare and highly muscular male sculptures has been photographed in the Upper Benue region (nor is anything comparable known from the entire Benue River Valley).

The most compelling evidence for the identities of these figures survives in the ceramic vessels (fig. 10.4) made by the Yungur to contain the spirits of deceased chiefs. Notice the similarities in the contours of their heads, facial features, caps, and thick elongated necks. These wooden sculptures may constitute a remnant of an abandoned memorial tradition that was preserved in the more enduring medium of ceramic. While it is difficult to ascribe a specific ethnic attribution to the wooden figures, it seems plausible that the idea for such effigies circulated in the Eastern Gongola Valley where communities of speakers of closely related languages shared cultural practices and material symbols.

Lesson 9: Spirit Identities in Clay

Background Information

To the east of the Gongola River, the roles and meanings of figurative ceramic vessels shift to an emphasis on the containment and representation of specific, named spirit deities and of ancestral spirits. The forms and decoration of these vessels are equally distinctive, and they too are modeled to express the visual and conceptual linkages between pots and people. Most dramatically, their “skins” reference the body modifications that help define social identities and responsibilities and the connections between people and their spirit protectors.

Most of the figurative ceramics on view were housed in shrine enclosures. On behalf of individuals and communities, ritual leaders made regular appeals to the spirits contained in the vessels to secure their positive intervention. By the 1980s many of these enclosures had collapsed or disappeared altogether, leaving their contents vulnerable to theft or destruction.

The Ga’anda peoples produce several ceramic vessel types to contain particular spirit forces, and these are enshrined together in enclosures (literally, “houses for pots”) and maintained by lineage custodians. Every year after the November harvest, ceremonies occur when the Ga’anda renew these shrines and make offerings to protective spirits via their ceramic representations. These pots lead lives like people: their houses need repair, their bodies need washing, and their appetites need satiating. They also look like people, and the raised and incised motifs on the vessels depict patterns of body scarifications on Ga’anda women, as well as tools and weapons carried by men. The identity of each Ga’anda ceramic deity is defined by its distinctive shape and decorative program. Their positive intervention was considered vital to Ga’anda health and well-being.

 

Lesson 8: Figurative Vessels of Transformation

Background Information

Ceramic vessels are the focus of ritual activities across the Upper Benue region, in most cases conceived to “contain” various kinds of spirit forces.

The forming and firing of a new vessel was an important part of a healing process. Symptoms were drawn into the vessel and away from the person who was in need of healing. The disease-causing spirit entered the clay in its raw “uncooked” state, and health was conferred after the vessel is transformed by fire. As fire transformed the pot, so too, the disease was contained and controlled.

The most common use for “healing vessels” was to protect pregnant women, mothers, and children. One vessel, to shield infants from disease, was modeled as a woman with a baby on her back. Such vessels range from the relatively naturalistic to the highly stylized, taking full advantage of clay’s plastic potential.

In addition to the healing vessels concerned with protection from disease, in the western Gongola Valley figurative pottery was used in rituals to protect hunters (and formerly warriors) against the avenging spirits of animals (or people) killed in the hunt or in war. Other “spirit pots” were connected with bringing rain, fostering good crops, and punishing thieves. Variants among the Waja peoples include small vessels (about 2–6") that serve as personal amulets, again in various forms depending on the disease being treated, and among the Tangale peoples a singular large figurative piece was transformed into a “power” sculpture with the addition of bicycle chains, bundles of sticks, horn, ax blades, pipes, and other materials, making it useful to protect the people. At least twice a year offerings were made in the form of added materials to keep the spirit active.

Spirit vessels were an integral component of traditions that served the collective needs of a particular community as they also addressed the unique requirements of individuals. And although the rituals differ from one group to another, their practices typically involve calling upon spirits to facilitate positive shifts in human destiny.

 

Lesson 7: Masquerades in the Middle Benue

Background Information

Animal/human, king/commoner, wild/domesticated, home/bush, male/female and living/dead are among the dichotomies that come together in fusion mask performances in this middle portion of the Benue River Valley. These masquerades were held especially at times of change such as rites for initiation, assumption of high office, changing of the seasons, and at remembrances of the dead. The resemblances between the masks are evidence of a set of broadly shared religious ideas. Worn horizontally on the head, the masks combine attributes of human (the skull-like shape of the head, human shaped eyes and nose, hair, scarification markings) and animal (horns, beaks, ears, jaws) (fig. 7.1). A variety of animal featured may be represented, but prominent are the horns of the dwarf forest buffalo or bushcow, pointing backwards or forming an almost-complete circle (fig. 7.2). Some of these masquerades were performed in gendered pairs with the females taking a distinctively different form. Frequently capes of flowing hibiscus fiber were attached directly to the horizontal masks sitting on top of the head.

Another distinctive mask form in the Middle Benue departs radically from horizontal orientation with its very tall appearance (fig. 7.3). These towering impersonations—vertical walking sculptures—slowly lumber en masse, slowly forward or sideways, with their heads soaring high above those of the living. These large and dramatic mask configurations were used by several neighboring peoples living on both sides of the Middle Benue River—the Mumuye, Wurkun/Bikwin, and Jukun. They are enigmatic because of their form—some of them perhaps not worn since the space between their lower planks is almost too narrow for a person’s head to fit—and because there are no detailed field observations about how they were performed. Scholars surmise that in some cases the performer stood inside the support and balanced the mask on top of his head, holding the lower portion to keep it steady and seeing through a hole or vision port (fig. 7.4). Others with solid planks or no vision port would have been worn with the wearer’s head turned sideways to see (fig. 7.5). Still others must have been carried by one or more men. Holes along the edges of the planks show that grasses were attached at the sides and bottom to disguise the wearer (fig. 7.6).

These objects were likely to have functioned less like conventional “masks” than as “walking sculptures,” appearing during harvest and planting festivals to bestow blessings of agricultural success and community well-being. Among the Wurkun/Bikwin peoples, they also incarnated ancestors who returned to the human world in spectacular ceremonies. 

 

Lesson 6: Middle Benue Iron Works

Background Information

The use of metallurgy in Western Africa dates to about 1500 bce and in the region of the Benue River Valley evidence of blacksmiths’ work has been found from the sixth century bce. The earliest known civilization to possess the knowledge of the manufacture and use of iron in sub-Saharan Africa is that of the Nok culture (so named after the village where works of art in terracotta and metal were first found in 1944). The Nok area, in fact, is not far from the Benue Valley, northwest of the Niger/Benue confluence.

Across the region—historically and still today—the most powerful markers of ritual authority included forged iron rattles (fig. 6.1), spears (fig. 6.2), knives, and wands. Iron has provided the material for affirmations of regal status and power and it has been fashioned into essential tools of everyday living including weapons, hunting gear, and farming implements, most notably the hoe. Iron, with intrinsic supernatural power, serves as means of communication with powerful natural and ancestral forces.

Consequently blacksmiths, those who worked with iron, acquired a distinct position in society as they created such charged implements drawn from the raw materials of nature itself.Important members of their community, blacksmiths often moved into other areas where their skills were needed, and even though the iron pieces were produced by local or regional specialists, their very portability led to widespread distribution among neighboring groups. 

 

Lesson 5: Ritual Intermediaries in Human Form

Background Information

Sculptures in human form were used as the focus of ritual activities across the Middle Benue region. The figures could stand in for specific ancestors, the collective dead, or spirits of the wild, all understood to be human-like in form. The dramatic, carved wooden figures served as intermediaries in rituals aimed at healing and protecting the community. Natural catastrophes such as epidemics and drought, and crises brought about by war and the slave trade all provided need for intervention. Important objects could be traded or sold along with the rituals used to activate them.

These ritual figures take a geometric form, differing from the more naturalistic maternal images of the Lower Benue. That they all have columnar torsos, encircling arms, short legs, heads with crest forms, and faces with rudimentary features demonstrates the dynamics of interaction and communication across the Middle Benue. Even with these correspondences, the figurative sculpture of the Mumuye, Jukun, Chamba, Wurkun, and Montol peoples exhibit enough stylistic difference to reveal local innovation and invention.

 

Lesson 4: The Circulation of Masquerades

Throughout the Lower (and Middle Benue) regions, masquerades are performed to incarnate ancestors, enforce social codes, support royal and chiefly authority, celebrate warriors, or to entertain.Among those on view in the Lower Benue section of the Central Nigeria Unmasked exhibition are videos of “tall ghost” masks, as well as an impressive elephant mask, crest masks worn on the top of the head, and three imposing helmet masks that are used in masquerades to honor royalty among the Igala peoples.

The circumstances of war, migration, and resettlement since the nineteenth century have meant that masks were and continue to be highly mobile. They could be taken as war booty, bought and sold, adopted with or without accompanying rituals, and altered to suit aesthetic or social requirements of a new community. Reinterpreted by new owners, their meanings changed in response to different contexts and needs.

As cultural boundary crossers, masquerade traditions also retain some traces of where they have been. Their names, origin stories, accompanying musical instrumentation, idiosyncratic dance steps, or special adornments are all clues to their historical path.

The following curriculum connections explore masks familiar to the peoples in the Lower Benue region.

 

Lesson 3: Lost Wax Casting along the Benue

Background Information

Centers for casting objects of bronze (typically an alloy of copper and tin) and brass (alloy of copper and zinc) have been identified across the Benue corridor, from its confluence with the Niger to its upper reaches near the Cameroon border. Metal headdresses, small-scale standing figures, leadership regalia, smoking pipes, and ritual weapons reflect a variety of aesthetic and technical approaches. Most of these objects are relatively unknown when compared with other now-famous, metalworking traditions from southern Nigeria: the ancient Yoruba finds linked to Ife, the royal arts of Benin, and the archaeological objects excavated at Igbo-Ukwu.

Bronze and brass works were used in both the daily and ritual lives of the many people living there, and although made in specific locations in the valley, their comparatively small size and portability led to wide dispersal of individual pieces. This distribution and influence, along with the fact that itinerant specialists might travel beyond their home villages practicing their art, led to noticeable similarities in styles and details as well as local distinctions. The difficulty in determining original sources of many of the works is compounded by the fact that objects cast from copper alloys were easily recycled. A smith merely needed to light the fire and melt and pour molten alloys into molds, thus transforming the old into something new and different. 

Many of the pieces have been made by lost-wax casting, a technique long documented in the Niger Benue region. As early as the sixteenth century, early explorers were impressed by the sophistication of the pieces made here. The process called for skills in both pottery and metalworking, some cast pieces receiving further embellishment by smiths who worked the metal with hammers and other tools, attaching additional elements to the piece.

Cast metal works throughout the Benue River Valley were held in high esteem for their beauty and durability and because their makers seemed to be employing special powers as they used fire to transform pieces of metal into sculptural forms. These attributes resulted in many pieces being made for or appropriated by high-status members of a community. 

Lesson 2: Lower Benue Artists

Most works in the exhibition Central Nigeria Unmasked: Arts of the Benue River Valley were created by artists whose names were not recorded or retained over time. Scholars have been able to document some works associated with particular artists (sometimes interviewing the artists themselves), so that we know more about their lives and the factors that contributed to their talents and expertise.

A small group of known Idoma and Igala carvers are included in the exhibition. Several were born around 1900 before British military patrols penetrated the region and were among the first generation to grow up under British colonial rule. They were mostly part-time specialist woodcarvers and fulltime yam farmers who lived in rural villages reachable only by footpaths or dry-season roads. According to scholar Sydney L. Kasfir, none of the artists from Idoma had traveled outside Idomaland, gone to school, spoken on the telephone, or learned how to read and write; yet they were experts at many now-forgotten skills such as hunting and brass casting, and were repositories of minute knowledge on every tree, plant, and bush animal.

Ochai, who died around 1950, remains one of the most famous Idoma artists. Unlike most, he was a fulltime sculptor and had commissions from many villages beyond his own. His pieces in the exhibition with whitened faces, frequently a feature of masks and figures of the region (fig. 2.1), reveal the influence of neighboring groups, especially the Igbo peoples of southeastern Nigeria. The faces display lines of small incisions along the sides of the face and down the center of the forehead that emulate patterns of facial scarification. Ochai’s works display a characteristically bold, expressive carving style.

Also living in Otobi was Oba who may have been mentored by Ochai. This would not have been typical, however, since no formal apprenticeship system existed among Idoma carvers. Although the Anjenu sculpture in fig. 2.2 is thought to be by Oba, it is said to lack the finesse of Ochai.

The artist Umale Oganegi lived and worked in Ukuaja village near the town of Dekina. When a child he fell from a tree and became seriously disabled. He took up woodcarving using wood that his younger brother would collect outside the village and cut for him. Eventually Umale became very well known in the Dekina area for the bold simplicity of his carvings of female shrine figures and animal-headed helmet masks. He also was known for figurative boxes with lids, which were made to hold cosmetics (fig. 2.3) or as frames for mirrors. 

The Idoma artist Oklenyi from nearby Okungaga spent time watching artists at work, and then practiced woodcarving in secret until he became a carver who was recognized for his talent by both Igala and Idoma clients. Oklenyi’s style is evident on his masks with multiple heads, each with a rounded mouth, neat rows of teeth, and scars curving upward from the edges of the mouth (fig. 2.4). Such multiheaded masks are carved throughout southeastern Nigeria.